12: The Da Vinci Code, Dan Brown
So.
At lunch, I made the following statement: "The Da Vinci Code is crap." It was pointed out to me I should read it before making such statements. So I read it.
It's crap.
There are three big problems with it:
1) Fact and fiction are mixed so much you don't know what's true and what's not. People are stupid enough already. No need to confuse them by telling them half-truths. Pick one: fact, or fiction. Don't toe the bloody line.
2) Tension is achieved by not telling the reader everything the characters know. That's a cheap trick of a hack. Don't do it. Truman Capote didn't like it Murder by Death, and neither does anyone else.
3) The puzzles are simplistic. If you're going to write a novel about codes and puzzles, at least try to think of something actually tricky. SOFIA and APPLE were near-instant guesses upon reading the poems. (Yes, yes...spoiler.)
It does have a good point: it sets a fun historical, religious, archaeological mood. So I'm reading Eliade's History of Religious Ideas now. It's interesting, and perhaps it will purge some of Dan Brown's nonsense from my mind.
At lunch, I made the following statement: "The Da Vinci Code is crap." It was pointed out to me I should read it before making such statements. So I read it.
It's crap.
There are three big problems with it:
1) Fact and fiction are mixed so much you don't know what's true and what's not. People are stupid enough already. No need to confuse them by telling them half-truths. Pick one: fact, or fiction. Don't toe the bloody line.
2) Tension is achieved by not telling the reader everything the characters know. That's a cheap trick of a hack. Don't do it. Truman Capote didn't like it Murder by Death, and neither does anyone else.
3) The puzzles are simplistic. If you're going to write a novel about codes and puzzles, at least try to think of something actually tricky. SOFIA and APPLE were near-instant guesses upon reading the poems. (Yes, yes...spoiler.)
It does have a good point: it sets a fun historical, religious, archaeological mood. So I'm reading Eliade's History of Religious Ideas now. It's interesting, and perhaps it will purge some of Dan Brown's nonsense from my mind.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home